What you need to know
Asian economies must wean themselves from dependence on an unpredictable United States.
One thing was clear from this weekend’s G20 summit. Asia and the world face many risks, and most of them emanate from the United States of America.
The Trump-Xi trade deal is a clear example. According to the statement from the White House, the United States has agreed not to increase tariffs from 10 to 25 percent. In return, China has agreed to buy a ‘substantial’ amount of exports from the United States to ‘reduce the trade imbalance between our two countries’.
This is not how economies work.
America’s trade deficit with China reflects its dependency on the Chinese to finance U.S. investment and consumption. China’s promise to buy a ‘substantial’ amount of U.S. agricultural goods, for example, will require U.S. farmers to expand production. Doing so will require investment. Given Americans do not save enough to finance this increase in investment, where does it come from?
The answer is overseas. This inflow of capital will push up the U.S. dollar, worsening the trade deficit. When the agricultural products are finally bought by China, the US dollar will go up again, worsening the trade deficit even further.
The "deal" between Trump and Xi will change the composition of the U.S. trade deficit – American farmers will undoubtedly be better off – but the deal will not change the underlying saving-and-investment behavior and will not, therefore, alter the overall trade balance.
The deal does, however, achieve plenty of other things. It undermines the rules-based global trading system. It will divert trade away from other countries, including Australia’s farmers and energy suppliers. It will do nothing to support global growth. It will do nothing to address the ongoing challenges in the trading system. It doesn’t even promise a reduction in the existing tariffs. This deal highlights that the United States is increasingly a source of risk for the world. America’s trade war is disrupting Asian supply chains. It threatens growth and prosperity throughout the region. Tightening financial conditions led by the U.S. Federal Reserve are shaking Asian financial and currency markets. A turbulent U.S. stock market is reverberating around regional stock markets.
Trump’s attacks on institutions such as the U.S. Federal Reserve at home and the World Trade Organization abroad threaten the predictability and certainty of policies that underpin investment and consumption. Elevated geopolitical tensions around the reimposition of U.S. sanctions on Iran risk cascading into other challenges in the region.
At the heart of these risks is enormous policy uncertainty. What will Trump do next?
The mid-term election results certainly weakened the Trump administration. A Democrat-controlled House of Representatives is a welcome constraint on his power. But wounded beasts are unpredictable. Trump might respond to weakness domestically by projecting strength abroad. U.S. presidents have limited influence when it comes to domestic policy. The opposite is true when it comes to foreign policy, particularly in trade, finance and security.
Trump’s next move will be heavily influenced by what happens in the U.S. economy. The economic recovery will soon be the longest in U.S. history. It began well before Trump entered the White House. Trump has used a strong economy to justify and expand his policy agenda. The economy is currently on full throttle with the stimulus of the Trump tax cuts superimposed on economic recovery.
But what happens if the US economy falters? Given that so many of the world’s risks are coming from the United States, the possibility that might happen warrants serious consideration.
In this week’s lead essay in East Asia Forum, Adam Triggs warns that all the indicators suggest that the next U.S. recession is right around the corner. It is a matter of when, not if, and the implications for Asia are significant. The region best get ready now.
As Triggs notes, signals that predict U.S. recessions are far from perfect. But what is striking right now is just how many of them are now flashing red.
One relates to the pattern of the U.S. business cycle. The U.S. economy has never gone longer than a decade without a recession, a milestone which is fast approaching.
Another is the monetary policy stance of the U.S. Federal Reserve. Four of the last five episodes of Fed rate rises have been followed by a recession. With the latest episode already underway, investors expect at least four more rate rises before December 2019.
Term spreads are another predictor flashing red. A flattening yield curve – when short and long-term interest rates start converging – has predicted every U.S. recession in the last 60 years.
Another recession predictor is how much spare capacity there is in the economy. The last 10 U.S. recessions were preceded by a closing of the output gap. The U.S. output gap is now near zero, employment is heading beyond full employment and, while inflation and wages are moving slowly, they are beginning to shift.
Triggs is not alone in his warning of a looming U.S. recession. Many are forecasting an upcoming U.S. recession. Bank of America Merrill Lynch, The Economist Intelligence Unit and two-thirds of the economists surveyed by the National Association for Business Economists all predict a recession around 2020.
The implications for Asia are as complicated as they are serious.
Triggs argues that, should the US economy in fact slow down, the U.S. Federal Reserve will need to resort almost immediately to quantitative easing or some other form of politically controversial unconventional monetary policy. The last time the United States did this it sent a wall of capital towards Asia. While Asian economies welcomed the increased capital inflows, they did not welcome the volatility it wreaked on their financial markets and exchange rates, let alone when the tide pulled back at the end of it.
What should Asia do?
Now is the time for Asia to build domestic buffers against external economic shocks wherever possible: in fiscal policy, monetary policy and the accumulation of foreign exchange reserves. But, when the shock actually hits, regional cooperation will be key to seeing it off. Strengthening regional crisis-response efforts, like the Chiang Mai Initiative Multilateralization and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)+3 Macroeconomic Research Office, is the starting point.
Building the political will and framework for effectively activating regional support is even more important. Better linking these regional mechanisms to global institutions, like the International Monetary Fund, is key to ensuring effective surveillance of risks and strong responses if things go bad. And putting in place adequate swap arrangements to buttress these regional and multilateral mechanisms is an essential supplement.
There is much that Asia can do to weather the upcoming storm. But it needs to fix the roof while the sun is still shining.
This piece is authored by the East Asia Forum Editorial Board, which is located in the Crawford School of Public Policy, College of Asia and the Pacific, The Australian National University.
Read Next: OPINION: Will the US-China Trade War Really Spur Taiwan's Companies to Leave China?
The News Lens has been authorized to republish this article from East Asia Forum. East Asia Forum is a platform for analysis and research on politics, economics, business, law, security, international relations and society relevant to public policy, centered on the Asia Pacific region.
TNL Editor: Nick Aspinwall (@Nick1Aspinwall)
If you enjoyed this article and want to receive more like it in your news feed, please be sure to like our Facebook page below.