Why US-North Korea Peace Negotiations Have Hit a Diplomatic Wall

Why US-North Korea Peace Negotiations Have Hit a Diplomatic Wall
Photo Credit: Reuters /達志影像

What you need to know

Diplomatic momentum has hit a standstill as the two sides cannot decide on the implementation of the four articles of the Singapore declaration.

By Nate Kerkhoff

During the lead up to the June 12 summit in Singapore between United States President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, some believed the armistice that ended the Korean War in 1953 would at long last be replaced by a formal peace treaty. Two months later, the diplomatic momentum has seemingly hit a wall.

The key issue is the differing views of the U.S. and North Korea on the order and scope of implementation of the four articles of the Singapore declaration. Pyongyang believes that halting missile and nuclear tests, decommissioning certain weapons sites and beginning the process of returning U.S. servicemen remains from the Korean War satisfies the agreement’s confidence-building measures. Now, Pyongyang is demanding progress on the remaining article and calling for the United States to make a “bold move” towards establishing a peace regime.

Security experts caution against giving in to North Korea’s demands, as Pyongyang is known to exploit ambiguities in agreements. The United States’ last major negotiation with North Korea was the Leap Day agreement in 2012 that involved Pyongyang halting uranium production and missile testing. Later that year, North Korea launched a satellite that was technically not a missile but contained missile technology and the agreement fell apart.

RTS1T0K4
Photo Credit: Reuters / TPG
A man in Seoul, South Korea walks past a TV news report on the dismantling of North Korea's Punggye-ri nuclear testing site on May 24, 2018.

But the North Korean leadership has reason to act with urgency on the issue of an official peace treaty. Besides the emotional significance of formally ending the tragic war that has kept North and South Korea separated and technically enemies for nearly 70 years, a peace treaty is a critical step in achieving Pyongyang’s security, economic and political objectives.

For most of its existence – and especially since the end of the Cold War – North Korea has operated in a constant state of threat due to the major military powers surrounding it. Pyongyang sees a peace regime as a means to finally move past this siege mentality and begin conducting normal relations with the world.

On the economic side, Kim Jong-un has declared the country’s nuclear development program complete and will focus his efforts on economic development. Not only is North Korea one of the world’s poorest nations, China accounts for around 90 percent of its trade. To avoid relying entirely on the bank of Beijing for financial backing, North Korea will need access to international financial institutions. But UN Security Council sanctions outlaw most commercial relations with North Korea, all but cutting it off from the international financial system and legitimate trade.

9qk8coprjyabpyipnu3mabzo751l7g
Read Next: Taiwanese Tourists Newly Welcomed into 'Mysterious' North Korea

Commerce and economic expertise from abroad are critical if the small impoverished nation wants to modernize. Though still a long way from adopting the authoritarian state-driven policies that helped other Asian countries achieve rapid economic growth in the past, Kim Jong-un has reportedly mentioned that he is serious about economic improvement and particularly interested in the Vietnam model.

North Korea believes that a formal peace treaty is an important step to shedding its international pariah state status. It cannot proceed with potential economic projects, such as those being discussed with South Korea and others, while still technically a belligerent and subject to crippling UN sanctions.

The North Korean regime also faces political challenges at home. Though the regime holds an iron grip over the population, the state police must scramble to prevent outside information from penetrating North Korea’s strict communication barriers. This has grown more difficult through the proliferation of USB drives smuggled from China and increased word-of-mouth interaction at markets throughout the country.

In the decades since the war, the vast North Korean propaganda machine that helps its leadership maintain control over the citizenry has been fueled by efforts to demonize the United States and, to a lesser extent, South Korea. Kim Jong-un took a political risk by agreeing to meet and strike deals with the leaders of his sworn enemies and by uncharacteristically broadcasting the events to the North Korean people. He is likely feeling internal pressure to show that he can deliver results.

The United States, on the other hand, remains steadfast in its demand for denuclearization before economic concessions and a formal peace treaty. Harry Harris, the newly appointed U.S. Ambassador to South Korea, reiterated this point by telling the South Korean press that North Korea must show “demonstrable moves toward denuclearization.”

RTS1T40D
Photo Credit: KCNA via Reuters
North Korea's nuclear test center was completely dismantled, shown in this undated photo released by North Korea's Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) in Pyongyang, May 24, 2018.

While Washington welcomes recent North Korean gestures as signs of progress in the two countries’ relations, its view is that the destruction of some weapons sites and returning some servicemen remains do not constitute steps towards ridding the nation of its nuclear weapons. Recent reports that Pyongyang may actually be increasing its efforts to produce weapons will not play well with U.S. negotiators.

The current impasse is a result of the vagueness of the Singapore declaration and the obstinate positions of each country. Without an established timeframe or process for accomplishing the declaration’s four articles, it was inevitable that the two nations would eventually come to a disagreement.

The two countries’ starkly different approaches were on display at the ASEAN ministerial meetings in Singapore in early August 2018. U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo repeated the United States’ demand of a “fully” denuclearized North Korea and warned countries against violating sanctions by engaging with Pyongyang economically.

Meanwhile, North Korean Foreign Minister Ri Yong Ho accused the U.S. side of hindering peace on the Korean Peninsula by “retreating” from peace treaty talks. Until the two sides find a middle ground for negotiations, North Korea’s economic plans will sit idle and one of history’s longest running wars will continue without formal peace.

542gpkst1qcanq2ux0pvcqpwtw0sz6
Read Next: CARTOON: Trump-Kim Summit Nails Human Rights in Nuclear Coffin

Nate Kerkhoff is a student at the Yonsei University Graduate School of International Studies.

The News Lens has been authorized to republish this article from East Asia Forum. East Asia Forum is a platform for analysis and research on politics, economics, business, law, security, international relations and society relevant to public policy, centered on the Asia Pacific region.

TNL Editor: Nick Aspinwall (@Nick1Aspinwall)

If you enjoyed this article and want to receive more like it in your news feed, please be sure to like our Facebook page below.


Tags: